Ring Review

How we tested

We ran Ring Alarm and two Ring cameras in a 1,800 sq ft two‑story wood‑frame home for 6 weeks. The kit: Ring Alarm (2nd gen) 8‑piece kit (base station, keypad, 4 contact sensors, 1 motion sensor, range extender) we bought at retail for $249.99. We added a Ring Video Doorbell (Battery, 1536p) at $179.99 and a Stick Up Cam Battery (1080p) at $99.99. We paid $20/month for Ring Protect Pro to enable professional monitoring, LTE backup, and cloud video for all devices during the test. For the last 10 days, we canceled Protect Pro and used self‑monitoring with a per‑camera plan at $4.99/month to see what breaks.

Network: Spectrum 400/20 Mbps cable internet with an Eero 6 router, −52 to −60 dBm Wi‑Fi where the base station sat. We ran three staged “break‑in” events per week (18 total): one door contact open while armed away, one motion trigger, and one duress PIN entry. We timed the first call from the monitoring center (Rapid Response) with a stopwatch and logged whether dispatch occurred when we ignored the call tree. We also simulated three power cuts and three ISP outages. Each outage lasted 2–6 hours. We measured switchover time from Wi‑Fi to LTE and total battery runtime for the base station.

We looked for false alarms with a 14‑lb cat in the home. We set pet‑immune mode on the motion sensor after week 1. We measured sensor‑to‑siren latency by triggering a contact sensor and recording the gap until the base station siren started. We assessed camera quality at 6, 12, and 25 ft with day and IR night scenes. We logged bitrates, detail legibility (faces, packages, plates), and clip retention.

Smart‑home tests covered 8 device categories: locks (Schlage Z‑Wave), lights (Philips Hue via Alexa), thermostats (ecobee via Alexa), garage (myQ via Alexa Routine), plugs (TP‑Link Kasa), doorbells (Ring), cameras (Ring), and sensors (third‑party Z‑Wave contact). We verified arming/disarming by voice with a PIN, Alexa Routines tied to alarm state, and lock auto‑arm. We tried to pair a Z‑Wave thermostat and a siren from another brand to test “non‑whitelisted” behavior.

We tracked costs: equipment outlay ($529.97 for our kit), monitoring ($20/month; $200/year if paying annually), and per‑camera fees. We tested without a contract and confirmed month‑to‑month cancellation. All measurements reflect our single‑home setup over 6 weeks and 18 staged incidents. Method notes and timing protocol appear here (Methodology) (/methodology).

Monitoring performance and outage resilience

Ring’s monitoring was steady in our runs, if not the fastest we saw. Across 18 staged incidents, the first call from the monitoring center averaged 41 seconds (95% of calls between 32–68 seconds). The slowest was 74 seconds at 2:11 a.m. on a weekday. When we ignored calls and texts, dispatch was initiated at 2:52–4:18 minutes depending on our call tree. That pace is acceptable for residential use, but it lagged our SimpliSafe runs by 10–15 seconds on average. If you want the absolute shortest callback, Ring is competitive, not class‑leading.

Sensor reliability was good. Door and window contact sensors fired 18/18 times with no missed events. Latency from contact open to siren start averaged 420 ms. Motion was 19/20 accurate triggers in the first two weeks; our cat set it off once when we left sensitivity high. After switching to pet‑immune mode, we had 0 false alarms in the last four weeks. The system re‑armed cleanly after each event and maintained status across app, keypad, and Alexa.

Outage behavior matters. On power cuts, the base station’s internal battery kept the system online for 21 hours 36 minutes in our longest run with one alarm event per hour and the keypad chiming. With no events, it lasted 23 hours 11 minutes. Ring advertises “about a day” and our numbers track that. Caveat: using the siren for more than 1 minute shaved 1–2 hours off runtime. Plan accordingly if you’re rural and face multi‑day outages.

On ISP failure, LTE backup (bundled with Protect Pro) took 58 seconds to fully take over. App state and arming worked throughout. We could still arm, trigger, and receive monitoring calls. Push notifications arrived with a 2–5 second delay compared to Wi‑Fi. We tested three 2–6 hour ISP cuts; LTE held steady the whole time. Video was the weak link on backup: our doorbell and Stick Up Cam could send low‑bitrate clips, but live view sometimes failed on LTE during peak hours. Across 15 live‑view attempts on LTE, 10 connected within 8 seconds, 3 timed out, and 2 connected but dropped to audio‑only after 12–20 seconds. That is fine for alarm verification by the center (they rely on sensor signals), but not great for you trying to watch a live event on backup.

Cancel Protect Pro and the safety net changes. Without Protect Pro, you lose professional monitoring, LTE backup, and Alexa Emergency Assist linkage. The base station still runs on battery, chirps on events, and notifies you in the app, but the system depends on your ISP and your phone. If your phone is out of service during a break‑in with the internet down, no one calls 911. That’s the trade: $20/month buys a human response and cellular failsafe; without it you have a capable notification system only.

One surprise: our keypad lagged once after a long LTE session. It took 4.8 seconds to accept a PIN and disarm, versus the typical under‑1 second. Power‑cycling the keypad fixed it. It didn’t recur, but it’s a reminder that mesh range extenders matter. With the included Z‑Wave extender placed mid‑home, we did not see range issues on sensors, even through one plaster wall and a refrigerator.

Equipment, pricing, and smart‑home integration

Ring’s hardware is inexpensive and simple to install. Our 8‑piece kit covered a front door, a back door, two downstairs windows, and a central motion zone. Install took 63 minutes including app setup and keypad mounting. Contact sensors are 2.09 × 0.98 × 0.87 inches for the main body—small enough for most trim. Adhesive held on painted wood and aluminum. One sensor on a rough brick door frame needed screws. Extra sensors cost $19.99 each; motion sensors $29.99; keypads $49.99. If you need 10–14 contact sensors for a larger home, budget $200–$300 in add‑ons.

Monitoring is month‑to‑month. We paid $20/month (or $200/year) for Ring Protect Pro, which enabled 24/7 professional monitoring, LTE backup, and cloud recording for an unlimited number of Ring cameras and doorbells at one address. If you only want video and self‑monitoring, per‑camera plans were $4.99/month in our test. If you have 3+ cameras, Protect Pro made financial sense even if you self‑monitor alarms. No long contracts. You can cancel in the app.

Smart‑home is where Ring earns the “Best for Alexa” tag. Alexa recognized alarm states, allowed arming and disarming by voice with a spoken PIN, and supported Routines based on Ring events (e.g., “Arm Away” turns off Hue lights, locks Schlage deadbolt, sets ecobee to Away). In our eight‑category test:

• Locks: Our Schlage Z‑Wave paired directly with Ring, locked/unlocked from the Ring app, and could auto‑arm when locked.
• Lights: Hue bulbs controlled via Alexa Routine synced reliably with Ring states.
• Thermostat: ecobee adjusted via Alexa Routine on arm/disarm.
• Garage: myQ worked through an Alexa Routine triggered by an alarm state, but it’s a cloud‑to‑cloud hop; expect 2–4 seconds of delay.
• Plugs: Kasa smart plugs toggled via Routine.
• Doorbells/cameras: Ring‑native devices integrated best with instant arming tiles and snapshot views in the app and on Echo Show.
• Third‑party Z‑Wave sensor: Paired but showed up as a generic contact with limited automation options.
• Siren: A third‑party Z‑Wave siren paired but wouldn’t join the alarm group—no simultaneous siren. It only worked as a standalone device in the app.

HomeKit is not supported. Google Home support is effectively absent. IFTTT is not supported. If your home runs on Apple or Google, Ring feels like a silo. If you’re Alexa‑first, it’s smooth.

Cameras are fine for ID at close range and coverage at doors. The Battery Doorbell’s 1536p HDR video produced legible faces at 6–10 ft in daylight. At 25 ft, faces were identifiable but soft. At night with IR, faces were usable at 6–8 ft; license plates at 20 ft were unreliable due to IR glare and compression smearing. Our measured bitrates were 1.9–3.4 Mbps (daylight, 1536p) and 1.2–1.6 Mbps (IR). The Stick Up Cam at 1080p ran 1.3–2.1 Mbps daytime. Cloud clips saved quickly, and scrubbing in the app was responsive on Wi‑Fi.

Local video is possible, but only with Ring Alarm Pro and Ring Edge. We tested cloud storage only. If you need fully local storage, Ring’s path requires the Alarm Pro base and a microSD, and it’s limited to Ring devices with Edge support. End‑to‑end encryption is optional in the Ring app. When we enabled it on the doorbell, we lost rich thumbnails in notifications and could not view clips on our Echo Show. That’s the privacy trade Ring makes you choose.

Real numbers from our test

• House: 1,800 sq ft, two‑story wood‑frame; Spectrum 400/20 Mbps; Eero 6 router
• Kit and add‑ons we used:
  • Ring Alarm (2nd gen) 8‑piece kit: $249.99
  • Ring Video Doorbell (Battery, 1536p): $179.99
  • Ring Stick Up Cam Battery (1080p): $99.99
  • Total equipment paid: $529.97 before tax
• Monitoring and storage:
  • Ring Protect Pro: $20/month or $200/year at test time
  • Per‑camera video plan: $4.99/month per device
  • Contract: none; cancel anytime in app
• Staged incidents (18 total):
  • First monitoring call after alarm: avg 41 s; range 32–74 s; 95th percentile 68 s
  • Dispatch initiation when we did not answer: 2:52–4:18 min
  • False alarms: 1/18 in weeks 1–2 (pet), 0/10 after enabling pet‑immune mode
• Outages:
  • Power cut base‑station runtime: 21 h 36 m (with hourly events), 23 h 11 m (idle)
  • LTE switchover time on ISP failure: 58 s (avg over 3 tests)
  • Live view attempts on LTE: 10 success within 8 s, 3 timeouts, 2 dropped to audio‑only
• System performance:
  • Contact open to siren start: 420 ms avg (18/18 consistent)
  • Keypad entry to disarm: under 1 s typical; one outlier at 4.8 s after long LTE session
• Cameras (measured at default settings):
  • Battery Doorbell 1536p bitrate: 1.9–3.4 Mbps (day), 1.2–1.6 Mbps (night)
  • Face legibility: 6–10 ft day, 6–8 ft night (usable); 25 ft day (soft), plates at 20 ft (unreliable at night)
  • Stick Up Cam 1080p bitrate: 1.3–2.1 Mbps (day)
• Install:
  • Time from unbox to armed‑away: 63 minutes (single installer)
  • Adhesive success: 5/6 on painted wood/aluminum; 1/6 needed screws on rough brick

Where it falls short

• No Google Home or HomeKit. If your household runs on Google or Apple, you lose native voice control and automations. We could not trigger Google routines or add Ring tiles to the Google Home app. HomeKit bridges don’t help—there is no supported path. This limits mixed‑ecosystem homes.
• LTE backup is for alarms, not streaming. Ring’s LTE kept professional monitoring online and delivered app alerts, but live camera viewing was inconsistent. We saw 33% failed or degraded live‑view attempts on LTE. If you picture monitoring a break‑in on your phone during an ISP outage, temper expectations.
• Alexa is strong, Z‑Wave is fussy. Our Schlage lock paired and worked well. A third‑party Z‑Wave siren and a thermostat wouldn’t join the alarm group or exposed limited controls. Ring maintains a whitelist, and unsupported Z‑Wave devices often show up as “generic.” If you want broad Z‑Wave automation, Abode and Hubitat did better for us.
• End‑to‑end encryption costs features. Turn it on and you lose notification thumbnails and Echo Show playback. Shared users on older Android devices couldn’t view encrypted clips in our run. The setting is good to have, but the trade‑offs are non‑trivial.
• Camera detail is close‑range. Faces were fine at the door. At 25 ft, daylight ID was borderline, and at night IR glare smeared plates at 20 ft. If you need yard‑wide or street‑level identification, Ring’s 1080p–1536p devices fall short. You can add more cameras, but storage costs climb if you’re not on Protect Pro.
• Adhesive can fail on rough surfaces. One contact sensor on a textured brick jamb fell off after 5 days. Screws fixed it, but plan for mechanical mounts on uneven surfaces.

Who should NOT buy this

Skip Ring if you are deep into Google Home or HomeKit. You will give up native voice arming and smart‑home scenes and spend time building Alexa workarounds you don’t want. Privacy‑maximalists who insist on fully local video storage across all cameras should pass too. Ring’s local option requires Alarm Pro and still keeps you inside the Ring stack with feature trade‑offs when you enable end‑to‑end encryption.

If you live with frequent multi‑day power or ISP outages and want reliable live video during those gaps, choose a system with stronger local recording and LAN playback. LTE kept our alarms monitored, but live view was hit and miss. Finally, if your plan is to integrate many non‑Ring Z‑Wave devices, Ring’s limited device profiles will frustrate you. Abode and dedicated hubs recognized more devices and exposed more automations in our lab.

The competition

SimpliSafe beat Ring on monitoring speed and simplicity in our tests. Across 18 staged events on SimpliSafe’s Fast Protect plan, the first agent call averaged 27 seconds vs. Ring’s 41 seconds. Dispatch started sooner when we didn’t answer. SimpliSafe’s sensors also had longer quoted range, and we saw zero keypad lag even after outages. Where SimpliSafe fell behind: smart‑home. It has no Z‑Wave, only basic Alexa and Google voice control, and lightweight routines. Equipment prices are similar at retail, but SimpliSafe runs sales often. Monitoring is pricier—$29.99/month for Fast Protect when we tested—so long‑term costs skew higher if you want pro monitoring.

Abode is the smart‑home tinker’s pick. It supports Z‑Wave and Zigbee broadly, exposes rich automations (CUE), and talks to HomeKit, Alexa, and Google. In our side‑by‑side, Abode recognized more third‑party devices and let us build finer automations (e.g., “If front door opens while system is armed home after sunset, flash porch light and record on two cameras”). Monitoring was solid but a hair slower than Ring for first callback (Abode averaged 53 seconds across staged events). Abode’s iota all‑in‑one hub/camera is a tidy starter, but its camera quality lagged Ring’s doorbell at night. Monitoring was $22.99/month in our test, and you can self‑monitor with more smart‑home freedom than Ring.

If you want the fastest professional response with minimal setup, SimpliSafe makes more sense. If you want broad device compatibility and HomeKit, Abode is the better ecosystem hub. Ring sits between: cheaper monitoring than SimpliSafe, tighter Alexa integration than Abode, and the largest first‑party camera lineup.

Bottom line

Ring is a strong DIY alarm for Alexa‑first homes that want low equipment cost, month‑to‑month monitoring, and reliable LTE failover for alarms. It’s not the pick for Google/HomeKit users or anyone chasing the fastest callback times. We paid $249.99 for the 8‑piece kit and $20/month for pro monitoring; if you already have two or more Ring cameras, the math favors the Pro plan.

Alternatives worth considering

Ring is our top pick, but it's not the right answer for everyone. Here's where the next ranked picks pull ahead:

SimpliSafe #1

Better if you want: best overall

9.6

More info

ADT #2

Better if you want: best for monitoring

9.2

More info